I was summarily confused when I found a remix of Scott-Herons work by Jamie xx (percussionist for the aforementioned band) on my desk.
In my opinion, The xx could stand to be remixed by Scott-Heron (adding some heart and soul), not the other way around.
Jamie xx makes Scott-Heron into his own personal sampling bank on "We're New Here" for a cold, electronic set of tunes that I dislike. The worst example of this is NY Is Killing Me, which takes an excellent tune and samples out various phrases like DontyouDontyouDontyouDontyouDontyou and Killing me-me-me-me-me-me-me before getting into a slightly longer bit of it 1:30 in.
Im all for reinterpretation (especially to those who may not of heard of his work, as some of Scott-Herons older catalog is used), but this hardly makes sense to what the soul icon is about. Theres no way to parse out the importance of his words when hes turned into a fragmented sample. The track isnt bad, but it just doesnt serve Scott-Herons work well.
But then again, this isnt the first remix Ive hated.
The Crutch pairs Scott-Herons words with a breakbeat, which makes no sense. Im New Here is a total re-envisioning of his words, removing the folk guitar and throwing down a spiky electronic backdrop. Seeing as the mans words were kept mostly intact, it passes as an understandable interpretation, but it doesnt anywhere approach the power of the original.
The only tune here that truly succeeds is Running, which was a highlight of Im New Here, too. The evocative words are paired to a rhythmic track that much more recalls hip-hop than DJ sets, and the pairing works incredibly well. Its the only cut here that doesnt beg to be compared to its former incarnation; the two can exist in their own spaces equally, because they are revealing different parts of the same work. It is not, as so many tunes are on this remix record, merely using Scott-Herons work, but repurposing it.
I am disappointed with Were New Here, especially with the elegance of Im New Here and Scott-Herons previous works powering it. At least theres not a new version of The Revolution Will Not Be Televised. That version, I guess, is being played out on our TVs. And maybe thats a sign that times have changed, and that maybe Scott-Heron does need to be a sound bite played over electronics.
But I still dont like it, even if Jamie xx is right. Stephen Carradini