Starting in 1994 on the East Coast, Justin Duerr did; he wondered what it meant. The more he encountered them, the more his interest was piqued. Curiosity beget obsession when an in-its-infancy Internet search yielded no results, and the documentary Resurrect Dead: The Mystery of the Toynbee Tiles follows Duerr in his roughly 15-year search for a solution.
An admirable alternative to the currently Sherlock Holmes sequel or any recent rentable and/or viewable mystery, really Resurrect Dead is not to be missed.
As debuting feature director Jon Foys film informs us, Toynbee refers to deceased historian/philosopher Arnold Toynbee, which is the lone clue Duerr had to pursue. His digging eventually uncovers tiles as far west as Kansas City, Mo., and as far south as South America. Sidebar messages and an eventual manifesto reveal the tile makers conspiracy theory about the cult of the hellion, a belief that the FBI is funneling info about him to the Soviets, and an instruction to readers to Murder every journalist. I beg you.
This whodunit is simultaneously a whydunit and howdunit, especially with the discovery of tiles in the middle of busy interstates. As Duerrs list of suspects forms and grows several lines deep, the documentary becomes as engrossing as any murder mystery by our finest fiction authors. So barbed are its tendrils that the puzzle branches out to include Stanley Kubrick, David Mamet and Larry King as important pieces. Like Errol Morris Tabloid, another wildly accessible doc ignored by this years Academy Award nominations, Resurrect Dead grows crazier at every turn.
Some of Foys re-enactments are a bit clunky; Duerr is no actor, but who expects that? I was nearly as hooked as he.
Resurrect Dead reminded me of an excellent nonfiction book from 2002, Tom Standages The Turk, which detailed the mystery behind an 18th-century chess automaton. Both works shed light on a relatively unknown stunt bundled tight with secrets, complete with one of those ah, but of course! V8 moments at the end.
The DVD includes a gallery of 15 tiles, complete with commentary by Duerr, Foy and company that comprises nearly half an hour; a nice, one-minute piece of the films four-note motif; and three deleted scenes, two of which explore the Spiricom, a 70s-era machine purported to allow for two-way communication with the dead. Its another conspiracy theory with the tiles that, while interesting, would have gotten in the way of the main narrative a narrative, need I remind you, that doesnt need any more mystery. It has plenty to spare, much to enjoy. Rod Lott