Strangers No More looks at a K-12 public school in Tel Aviv, where students from 48 countries unite as one. Children is children. In education, theres no strangers, says the principal. And everyone has a special story. A real complicated story. Shes not joking. Many of the kids have never set foot in a classroom before, for whatever reason, some tragic. Expect some tears on the academic years final day.
Poster Girl refers to Robynn Murray, a middle-American girl and she is indeed still a girl who went from high school cheerleading to manning tanks as an Army sergeant in Iraq. Sexual harassment was the least of her problems, as she now suffers from a crippling case of post-traumatic stress disorder that, on occasion, makes her want to cease living. It doesnt help that the federal system to aid veterans seems so wrought with red tape that one wonders if it wasnt intentionally designed to hinder rather than help; either way, it only adds to her immense level of stress.
A different kind of war is the focus of Killing in the Name, centering on a terrorist incident in 2005 in Jordan, where a suicide bomber took out 27 members of a wedding party. The film follows the groom in his crusade for answers (They dont have the right to kill people in the name of God), confronting the bombers father, attempting to speak to the al-Qaida recruiter, and denouncing the Islamic extremists (not, please note, the entire religion).
The other two films, Sun Come Up and The Warriors of Qiugang, look at threatened communities, in entirely different ways. In the former, the Carteret islanders face rising waters that may not only wipe out their crops and land, but their entire culture; in the latter, Chinese villagers fall ill to factory-polluted wall. In the former, they dont want to leave the place they were born; in the latter, they wish they were born elsewhere.
WIN THE POOL!
Oscar-contest victories often are ensured by correctly predicting the obscure categories, of which documentary short subjects is one. Id say your guess is as good as mine, except Ive seen all five. Then again, consider the subject matter education, war, terrorism, climate change and environmental hazards and each seems readymade to curry the Academy members guilt vote.
But Sun and Warriors cancel one another out by similarity. For me, Poster Girl is the most interesting; Killing, the most shocking; Strangers, the sweetest ... but sweetest wont make it to the podium.
Based solely on the one that moved me the most, Ill be rooting for Poster Girl on Oscar night both the film and its star.